Cherokee Purple vs Black Krim Tomatoes – In-Depth Comparison

Are you also searching for the actual difference between Cherokee Purple vs Black Krim Tomatoes? This article will be a guide for you to understand the differences between Cherokee Purple and Black Krim Tomatoes. Let us get started. As you have made your way to this article that means You are likely into dark-colored and spotted tomatoes. They are already super popular. So I guess why not!? When we think of black tomatoes, Cherokee tomatoes, and Black Krim tomatoes’ names always show up. And we people always get confused between these two in so many ways. But worry not! We have got you covered and will clear your doubts. But first, let us know what these tomato varieties actually are!

Key takeaways:

  • Cherokee purple’ is named Cherokee because of the dark purple color they have and the deep flavor they give.
  • ‘Black Krim’ is named black krim because they are Ukrainian and they have dark colors almost looking like black in hot times of the year.
  • Some points showing differences between them are their sizes, flavor, maturity time, their color, type, shape, etc.

What are Cherokee purple tomatoes?

Solanum lycopersicum ‘Cherokee purple’, are heirloom varieties that have dark rose color and green shade on the shoulders. They are known for their rich and juicy flavor. They are named ‘Cherokee purple’ because of the dark purple color they have and the deep flavor they give. These tomatoes are like beefsteak and are produced from the cross between two heirlooms Cherokee purple and carbon. 

What are Black Krim tomatoes?

Solanum lycopersicum ‘Black Krim’ is an almost black-colored variety of tomatoes. They are heirloom tomatoes that turn darker in the summer season, though they are open-pollinated and have deep red to purple color. if tomatoes do not turn red there will be some reasons behind it such as cold, water, variety, etc. Black Krim tomatoes are super juicy. They are named ‘Black Krim’ because they are Ukrainian and they have dark colors almost looking like black in hot times of the year. The Black Krim tomatoes are not hybrids but there are many hybrid tomatoes; they are made naturally by open pollination, which is the natural method. 

Cherokee Purple vs Black Krim Tomatoes(Differences)

Both the Cherokee tomatoes and Black Krim tomatoes have a lot of similarities between them, even though they look a lot like each other.l but the underlying differences can help you differentiate between these two. 

Between their sizes 

These flattened-looking tomatoes have little difference in their sizes. You might be thinking which is the largest tomato of these two? Then Cherokee purple tomatoes are larger-sized tomatoes than Black Krim tomatoes. 

Cherokee tomatoes have a size of approximately 8 to 16 ounces whereas the Black Krim tomatoes have a size of approximately 8 to 12 ounces, even the Cherokee tomatoes have larger growing periods than the Cherokee tomatoes. The Cherokee purple with the proper care can exceed the given measurements. 

Between their flavor 

Again being so close these tomatoes have fulfilled the user’s need with their flavors. Though little difference still exists between these two. Nonetheless, these both tomatoes are juicy, the Cherokee tomatoes have a deep rich rich flavor with a hint of smokiness in the fruit whereas the black Krim tomatoes being that dark has a tarty, sweet flavor, and with full of richness.

To know more about the plant world, you may also read related articles, Holy Basil vs Basil – What’s the actual difference?

Krim tomatoes are known for their savory flavor whereas Cherokee tomatoes are popular in the US with their smoky flavor. Though both varieties give a good tangy burst in the mouth. 

Between their maturity time 

The Cherokee purple needs a little more time to mature and get to a larger size than Black Krim tomatoes. Cherokee tomatoes and black Krim tomatoes are best grown in the mid-season the Cherokee variety needs 80 to 85 days to reach maturity whereas the black Krim tomatoes need 80 days to mature to be harvested. There are the different suitable seasons for different varieties of tomatoes and depending on the location for example Planting Tomatoes in Pennsylvania is recommended from April to May.

Between their color, type, and shape

Cherokee tomatoes and black Krim tomatoes both are indeterminate types that will not have a limit for ground tomatoes. These types will keep on growing and giving globe-like large fruits. The frost time when it enters, these plants then become dead or rarely dormant. 

The black Krim tomatoes have deep reddish purple flesh with green or brown shaded shoulders, almost like Cherokee tomatoes. 

Similarities between Cherokee purple tomatoes and Black Krim tomatoes 

The previous paragraph slides us to the similarities between the Cherokee Purple and Black Krim tomatoes. Both the tomatoes are beefsteak and make great sandwiches. Cherokee tomatoes and black Krim tomatoes grow in almost similar conditions: moist, fertile soil, no frost, liquid fertilizers, etc. 

It is recommended to sow the seeds indoors about 3-4 weeks before the last frost. Wait for the temperature to reach near 10 degrees Celsius(50 degrees Fahrenheit) and then it’s safe to move outdoors. 

Also, the liquid fertilizers should be added to the soil every two weeks, both of these plants will thank you for this. 

Which tomatoes to go for? Black Krim or Cherokee purple? 

Though both of them are amazing varieties to grow in your garden such as heirloom tomatoes,Dwarf Mr. Snow Tomato, Aerogarden Tomatoes, etc it’s not easy to make a decision to choose one. But if you want one name, I would say black Krim tomatoes because they are a bit mysterious for me looking all that black and giving sweetness in the mouth. Even these varieties are more disease resistant than Cherokee purple tomatoes. Otherwise, I would say both of them are great to be in your garden. Just plant them both! 

Final words for the context

We hope you like this article and find it useful. Both the black Krim tomatoes and Cherokee purple tomatoes are popular for the texture and flavor they give. In this article, you came to know about the similarities and differences they hold. By now we hope you have made up your mind about whether you are going or both or a single one. Do let us know what option you are going for. Happy growing up! 


How tall do Cherokee purple tomatoes grow? 

The Cherokee purple tomatoes are deep red colored and look deliciously good. I mean no one can stop them from eating them for their attractiveness. When you are growing the Cherokee tomatoes at home, you will see that they reach a height of 3-4 inches and the vines extend up to 13 cm. 

How tall do Black Krim tomato plants get? 

The Black Krim tomatoes just like Cherokee tomatoes or most of the other tomatoes are vine-like that need stakes for good support. The plants can get to a height of 4-6 feet. 

Becky Decker

Becky Decker, our esteemed Editor-in-Chief, is a passionate gardener with years of experience in the world of horticulture. With her guidance, aims to be your trusted companion on your gardening journey. Featured In   Becky Decker’s expertise and gardening wisdom have been recognized and featured in various prominent publications, including: Yahoonews  Experience & Background   Becky Decker’s love for gardening has been a lifelong journey. She has honed her skills through countless seasons of planting, nurturing, and harvesting a wide variety of plants, flowers, and vegetables. Her deep-rooted knowledge is complemented by her Bachelor’s degree in Horticulture from the University of Green Valley.   Prior to leading, Becky worked as a garden consultant, helping countless individuals turn their outdoor spaces into vibrant, thriving gardens. Her experience spans over a decade, making her a trusted authority in the gardening community.   The Birth of   Inspired by her passion for gardening and her desire to share her expertise with a wider audience, Becky Decker launched in 2021. This platform serves as a hub for gardening enthusiasts of all levels, from beginners to seasoned pros.   At, we are committed to providing you with comprehensive guides, expert advice, and hands-on tips to help you achieve success in your gardening endeavors. Whether you have a small balcony garden or a sprawling backyard paradise, we have the information you need to make your garden flourish.   Our Mission is more than just a gardening website; it’s a community of gardeners who share a common love for nurturing the Earth. Our mission is to empower you with the knowledge and resources to create beautiful, sustainable gardens that bring joy and tranquility to your life.   Join Us on This Green Journey   We invite you to explore and embark on your gardening journey with us. Whether you’re seeking advice on planting techniques, pest control, landscaping ideas, or the latest gardening trends, you’ll find it all right here.   Connect with us, ask questions, and share your gardening stories. Together, we’ll cultivate a thriving community of gardeners and help each other make the world a greener, more beautiful place.   Let’s dig in and grow together at, where gardening dreams bloom!

You may also like...

Ask in Community