Seed Starting Mix Vs Potting Soil – Which to use? – Seed Starter Soil

We understand how confusing some parts of the planting process can be, one of which is choosing the right soil mix! So let us throw some light on the debatable topic of Seed Starting Mix vs Potting Soil. Gardening is a great way to get your hands dirty and learn about plants.

Quick takeaways:

  • If you’re not familiar with gardening basics like soil, you may be at a disadvantage when it comes to growing plants.
  • We will compare seed starting mix vs potting soil and help you decide which one is best for your needs.
  • We will also provide some tips on how to make the most of each soil type so that you can start your gardening journey with success.

So read on to learn more about seed starting mix vs potting soil and which one is right for you!

All about Seed Starting Mixes

Starting seeds in a soil mix is a popular way to get plants off to a fast start, but there are many different mixes available. Some are made with just potting soil, some with amended soil and compost, and some with a combination of both. Which mix to use depends on the plant species and the gardener’s preferences.

Types of some common seed starting mixes:

Potting Soil Mix – This is the most common type of seed starting mix and contains only potting soil. It is sufficient for most plants, but some may require an amendment such as fertilizer or seaweed extract.

Commercially Available Seed Starting Mixes – These mixes contain various amendments including potting soil, compost, and fertilizer. They are designed for growing particular types of plants, so be sure to read the instructions before using them.

DIY Seed Starting Mixes – This type of mix can be created from any combination of ingredients that will provide fertility and moisture for plants. Additions such as composted manure or worm castings can give your plants an extra boost in growth.


While there are many different seed starting mixes in the market, it is important to choose one that will provide the best possible environment for your plants. Make sure to read the instructions on the package of the mix carefully before purchasing so you know what ingredients are included and how best to use them.

To know more about the plant world, you may also read related articles, Does Potting Soil go Bad? (How to check if it’s still Usable)

Seed Starting Mix Vs Potting Soil – Which to use?

Starting a garden from seed can be a fun and satisfying project, but it’s also an important one. You need to select the right plants and soil mix for the particular variety of seed you are growing, and making a good start can make all the difference. Here we compare two popular methods of starting seeds: using seed starting mix and using potting soil.

About Seed Starting Mix

The seed starting mix is a combination of premium organic ingredients, like peat moss, perlite, and vermiculite, that have been specifically designed for starting seeds. This mixture helps to improve the germination rate of your seeds by providing them with everything they need to begin growing: moisture, nutrients, and warmth. When mixed with water, the seed starting mix becomes a perfect medium for germinating your seeds.

One downside to using a seed starting mix is that it is not very consistent in terms of texture. Some batches will be thick and heavy while others will be runny and thin. This inconsistency can make it difficult to evenly moisten all of your seeds at once, which can lead to poor germination rates. You can also use fertilizer for seeds. Additionally, some seed starting mixes contain fungicides or other chemicals that could harm your plants if applied incorrectly. Always read the label before using any garden supplies!

How to choose a seed starting mix?

When starting seeds indoors, there are a few different options to choose from when it comes to seed starting mixes. Both potting soil and seed starting mixes can be used, but which one is best for you depends on the type of plants you plan to grow.

To help make the decision easier, we’ve put together a list of factors to consider when choosing a seed starting mix:

  • Plants you want to grow
  • How big do your plants need to be?
  • What kind of care do you want to give them?
  • How much money are you willing to spend?

About Potting Soil

Potting soil is made up of mineral ingredients like sand, screened gravel, and composted manure that has been blended until they form a loose mixture that

How to choose potting soil?

Choosing the right potting soil is important for successful seed starting. There are a lot of different types and qualities of soil available, so it can be hard to decide which one is best for your plants. Here are some tips on how to choose the right potting soil:

  • Look for soil that is well-balanced and has a good blend of ingredients. Good potting soil should have plenty of organic matter, nutrients, and drainage properties.
  • Consider the type of plant you’re growing. Some plants need sandy soils while others need loamy ones.
  • Think about your climate. Do you live in a hot or cold climate? Certain soils will be more appropriate for certain plants in those climates.
  • Think about your gardening experience and preferences. Some people prefer to mix their soils, while others buy pre-made mixes. It’s up to you which method you prefer!

Seed Starting Mix Vs Potting Soil – Major points of differences for a better understanding

Here’s a breakdown of the differences between seed starter mix and potting soil:

Seed Starter Mix

  • Is made of 50% organic matter (compared to 30% in potting soil).
  • Has a higher concentration of micronutrients (vitamins and minerals).
  • May be used in direct sow mode or as a germination aid.

Potting Soil

  • Is made up mainly of clay and sand and has lower concentrations of nutrients (especially nitrogen).
  • Is often used in indirect sow mode or when seeds don’t require a lot of fertilization.
  • Can also be used as a planting medium for potted plants.

Why is it important to make the right choice for a Seed Starting Mix?

Choosing the right seed starting mix can make all the difference when it comes to success with your garden. While there are many different seed starting mixes in the market, it is important to choose one that will provide the best possible environment for your plants. Make sure to read the instructions on the package of the mix carefully before purchasing so you know what ingredients are included and how best to use them. While there are many options available, some of the most popular mixes include composted soil or Miracle-Gro’s All-In-One Seed Starting Mix.

About Composted soil

Composted soil is made up of a variety of plant matter like dead leaves, grass clippings, and manure that has been mixed with sand and soil. This mixture provides a good balance of essential minerals and vitamins for plants to grow properly.

About Miracle-Gro’s All-In-One Seed Starting Mix

Miracle-Gro’s All-In-One Seed Starting Mix is another popular option. This mix contains perlite, which helps improve drainage and aeration, and vermiculite, which helps retain moisture and nutrients. Both options are available in premixed bags (for those who want to get started right away) as well as loose ingredients (for those who would like more control over their mix).

Can you use seed starting potting mix as potting soil?

The answer to this question depends on what you want to use the mix for. If you are starting seed planting in a container and plan on moving them to a larger pot or planting them into the ground later, then using seed starter soil is fine. If, however, you want the plants to grow in a small space, then using a potting mix is better.

There are several reasons why a seed starting mix would be better for small plants. First of all, it is usually more densely packed with nutrients than potting soil, which means that the plants will get more out of it. Secondly, it is easier to transplant plants into smaller pots from a mixture of seed starter mix and potting soil than from actual potting soil.

What is the best soil mix for seedlings?

There are many factors to consider when deciding what soil mix to use for seedlings. One of the most important considerations is the pH level of the soil. Seed starting mixes typically have a higher pH level than potting soils, which is beneficial for growing plants in a confined space. Some other factors to consider when selecting a soil mix for seedlings include the type of plant you are growing and the climate where you plan on planting your seeds.

Some popular types of seed starting mixes include coco coir, peat moss, vermiculite, perlite, and composted manure. When choosing a seed starting mix, make sure to read the ingredients list to determine if it is compatible with your plants. Some common problems that can occur when using incompatible soils include poor growth, wilting, and root rot.

Concluding lines

In this article, we have compared seed starting mix vs potting soil and have helped you in deciding which one is best for your needs. We have also provided some tips on how to make the most of each soil type so that you can start your gardening journey with success. So we hope we have fulfilled the readers’ purpose through this article!

Thanks for reading! Happy gardening!


Is a seed starter the same as a potting mix?

Seed starting mix and potting soil are both types of gardening soil. However, they have different purposes. Seed starting mix is designed to help you get your seedlings off to a good start, while potting soil is meant to be the perfect growing medium for plants.

What kind of soil should I use to start seeds?

If you are starting seeds in the soil, there are a few things to consider. First, make sure the soil is warm and moist before beginning. Second, select a type of soil that is best suited for your plant’s needs. Third, add appropriate amounts of seed starting mix to the soil and mix well. Finally, plant the seeds and water them well.

How long can seedlings live in the seed-starting mix?

A seed starting mix is a great way to get started in gardening because it offers both convenience and flexibility. However, the seed starting mix won’t last as long as potting soil, so you’ll need to rotate it every few years. Seedlings can live in seed starting mix for around two months before they start to show signs of stress, such as wilting leaves or reduced growth. After two months, seedlings should be moved into a potting soil mixture.

Becky Decker

Becky Decker, our esteemed Editor-in-Chief, is a passionate gardener with years of experience in the world of horticulture. With her guidance, aims to be your trusted companion on your gardening journey. Featured In   Becky Decker’s expertise and gardening wisdom have been recognized and featured in various prominent publications, including: Yahoonews  Experience & Background   Becky Decker’s love for gardening has been a lifelong journey. She has honed her skills through countless seasons of planting, nurturing, and harvesting a wide variety of plants, flowers, and vegetables. Her deep-rooted knowledge is complemented by her Bachelor’s degree in Horticulture from the University of Green Valley.   Prior to leading, Becky worked as a garden consultant, helping countless individuals turn their outdoor spaces into vibrant, thriving gardens. Her experience spans over a decade, making her a trusted authority in the gardening community.   The Birth of   Inspired by her passion for gardening and her desire to share her expertise with a wider audience, Becky Decker launched in 2021. This platform serves as a hub for gardening enthusiasts of all levels, from beginners to seasoned pros.   At, we are committed to providing you with comprehensive guides, expert advice, and hands-on tips to help you achieve success in your gardening endeavors. Whether you have a small balcony garden or a sprawling backyard paradise, we have the information you need to make your garden flourish.   Our Mission is more than just a gardening website; it’s a community of gardeners who share a common love for nurturing the Earth. Our mission is to empower you with the knowledge and resources to create beautiful, sustainable gardens that bring joy and tranquility to your life.   Join Us on This Green Journey   We invite you to explore and embark on your gardening journey with us. Whether you’re seeking advice on planting techniques, pest control, landscaping ideas, or the latest gardening trends, you’ll find it all right here.   Connect with us, ask questions, and share your gardening stories. Together, we’ll cultivate a thriving community of gardeners and help each other make the world a greener, more beautiful place.   Let’s dig in and grow together at, where gardening dreams bloom!

You may also like...